Tuesday, September 25, 2012

Logline Critique Round One #21

TITLE: The Withering of Amblethorn
GENRE: YA - Science Fiction

The girls of an exclusive New England school are disappearing and two unlikely friends are left to figure out who - or what - is behind it.

14 comments:

Holly Bodger said...

This is missing the why. WHY must these girls complete this mission?

Good luck!
Holly

Leah Petersen said...

I agree with Holly. Why are these two trying to figure it out rather than just going to the police? Also, "unlikely friends" is too ambiguous to give me any sense of who's involved here and if they'll interest me.

Walter said...

Are these girls students at this school and worried they'll be next? If so, make that explicit. If not, make explicit why they're the ones who must solve this.

Marianne Su said...

While I like this, I think you can add more tension to this, give it a hook.

LMF411 said...

Maybe expand the unlikely friends bit...

Cristin Bruggeman said...

I agree about expanding on the unlikely friends. Maybe character names and a couple of descriptive words that show instead of tell that these girls wouldn't normally work together.

GSMarlene said...

Yep, more about the unlikely friends. And are they left as the only ones alive or because everyone else went home for Christmas break?

Sounds like fun!

Abbe Hoggan said...

I agree it needs more, especially about the characters and the stakes.

Ink in the Book said...

I think this sounds great, but it does leave some questions unanswered. Why are they unlikely friends? why is it up to them to find out who is behind the disappearances?

Answers those and you may have a winner:)

Dale Ibitz said...

I'd like to see something about the characters...I like the premise in the first half of the sentence. Intriguing!

Natasha said...

Looks like you received some great feedback. I love your stab at brevity - you got the right idea - it just needs an electric shock treatment.

Love the title, but would you consider just using "The Withering"(?) "Withering" is an excellent word - does it reflect what happens to the disappearances? If so, I would elude to that in the logline. Nice stuff.

Anita Saxena said...

I'm just resonating with the others. I like this but want to know what makes these girls "unlikely."

Bonnie Staring said...

Good stuff! Agree with the other comments. Give us why they're unlikely friends and why they must solve the mystery.

Barbara said...

I think there's not enough here. Their goal is to find out what or who is behind the disappearances. What's missing is what stands in their way of figuring it out. And why do they want to figure it out? Why don't they just run for their lives?